Friday, April 04, 2008


Rating : 4.0/5
Number of Pages : 96
Reason for Reading : Once Upon a Time Challenge and extra for Graphic Novel Challenge

The tale follows a grown man as he looks back and remembers his childhood and various family members who are no longer alive. He remembers his grandfather who sold his grocery business and opening an amusement arcade in the town. It has a mermaid (a lady in a costume and wig who sings on a rock), a ghost train, hall of mirrors and a Punch and Judy show. Sadly no one comes to it as it is not on the main pier and even when it is raining the people stay away so sadly it has to close.

It looks at the story of Punch and Judy as well as a couple of characters no longer in the show like Punch's girlfriend. I had forgotten how grim the tale is. Punch starts by throwing the baby out of the window and then beating Judt to death when she shouts at him. He then beats the polieman to death who tries to arrest him, a physician, a crocodile, a hangman (he tricks him into the hangmans noose in his place) and finally the devil himself. At the end Punch is happy as everyone is now free to do what they want with the devil having been killed. The adult narrating the story remembers how he was frigtened of the tale as a child and it is easy to see why.

It is also a look at the innocence and naivety of childhood. There is a secret past concerning his grandfather that he never picked up on as a child as well as an unexplained tale about his uncle. There are various references throughout the story saying that he now thinks differently. It did enjoy this graphic novel with the range of different illustrations by Dave McKean. A dark trip back down memory lane.

4 comments:

Trish said...

Sounds very interesting--one day I really need to read something by Gaiman. Throughout my college courses I heard snippets about Punch and Judy, but I really don't know the history. Looks like this one might give some background...?

Nymeth said...

I enjoyed this one a lot as well. I need to read Violent Cases. I heard that it shares the themes of memory, childhood and nostalgia.

Carl V. said...

I'm not sure why I don't have a copy of this. Need to remedy that soon!!!

Framed said...

I really enjoy Neil Gaiman, but I've never read any graphic novels. Probably should do something about that.